Ten Essential Westerns
February 2nd 2011 02:14
by Matt Shea
The Magnificent Seven
The Wild Bunch
3:10 to Yuma
Once Upon a Time in the West
The Unforgiven
High Noon
The Quick and the Dead
The Good, the Bad, the Weird
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
Blazing Saddles
Critics are lavishing plenty of praise upon True Grit, but few are willing to predict a true return of the western. As any pipe-smoking dad knows, many of the greatest films ever involved six-shooters, spurs, horses and broads belles. So, in an effort to kickstart a revival, 20/20 Filmsight has rounded up some essential westerns that’ll get the gents chewing tobacco and the ladies swinging their parasols. What follows isn’t necessarily a list of the best films in the genre, but these are all worthy of your attention.
The Magnificent Seven
The Magnificent Seven has in more recent years become known as the Hollywood version of Akira Kurosawa’s Seven Samurai, which is a bit of a shame because this is a quality film in its own right, packed full of gun slinging and star power (it also ignores the fact that Kurosawa’s film was itself a descendent of early American westerns). One of the last positive-minded Hollywood films about American adventurism abroad, The Magnificent Seven produced three sequels, as well dozens of imitations. Brynner, McQueen, Bronson, Vaughn and Coburn: a hard bunch to stay away from.
The Wild Bunch
Forget revision: The Wild Bunch is pretty much 145 minutes of ruthless western deconstructionism. Released into a late 60s environment brimming with anti-Vietnam discord, the film polarised audiences via its epic bloodshed. It might kick like a mule, but that tends to overshadow the fact that The Wild Bunch is built upon a compelling script, courtesy of Walon Green.
3:10 to Yuma
I remember Dave O’Connell labelling the modern interpretation of 3:10 to Yuma as ‘muscular’. That’s a great way to sum up this 2008 feature, which rises above the pack with some sharp screenwriting and adept handling of action. Australian readers should ignore the panning it received locally upon local release, a misunderstanding down in part to some confusing billing: it’s Christian Bale’s Rancher Evans whom the film follows, as he strives to secure his farm, as well as the respect of his son, by delivering outlaw Ben Wade (Aussie Russell Crowe) to the authorities.
Once Upon a Time in the West
Sergio Leone’s Dear John to the western, Once Upon a Time in the West is perhaps the only film that recounts the death of its own genre, effortlessly flipping the regular conventions on their head. Epic in scope, measured in pace and brutal in its action, Once Upon a time is also the western that classicists, revisionists and spaghettios can all seem to agree on, perhaps by default making it the greatest ever.
The Unforgiven
‘Deserve’s got nothin’ to do with it.’ Thus Clint Eastwood summed up his own revionist take on the western, the gnarled and morally doomed William Munny dispatching Gene Hackman’s tyrannical Little Bill. The Unforgiven led to a renaissance for the genre in the 90s, but none of the films it inspired had the willingness to poke around their own genre like this slow-burning piece of bitter brilliance.
High Noon
If The Wild Bunch was a reaction against the Vietnam War, High Noon was a filmmaker’s early 50s stand against McCarthyism. Described by the politically out of touch John Wayne as the most un-American movie he’d ever seen, High Noon is a film about social and private responsibility, and in a sense, a western for people who don’t like westerns. Regardless, town marshal Wil Kane’s (Gary Cooper) countdown to the arrival of the Miller gang is one of the most frightening in cinema history.
The Quick and the Dead
The oddball nature of The Quick and the Dead was enough to curve ball many people into letting it pass by. That’s their loss, because this is a sharp, post-modern take on the western, given lashings of style courtesy of Sam Raimi and DOP Dante Spinotti (best known for his work with Michael Mann). Despite its stylish leanings, this also has some interestingly drawn characters. If you can handle Sharon Stone, Russell Crowe and Leonardo DiCaprio – three of the more divisive figures in modern cinema all in the same flick – then you should check this out.
The Good, the Bad, the Weird
One of the poster boys for the rise of Korean cinema, The Good, the Bad, the Weird certainly isn’t the greatest western you’ll ever see, but in terms of pure spectacle it’s hard to top. This is a film with very little story but built around some truly spectacular set pieces. Its characters barely register and proceeds sag badly towards the end as our trio (‘The Good’ – Jung Woo-Sung, ‘The Bad’ – Lee Byung-hun, ‘The Weird’ – Song Kang-ho) are pursued by the late 30s Japanese army across the Korean peninsula, but The Good, the Bad, the Weird is worth it just on the strength of its ‘diving bell helmet’ scene.
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
Released the same year as The Wild Bunch, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid took a different route in its revisionism, playing the death of the cowboy for laughs rather than ruthless violence. Still, no matter how charming and likeable they are, Butch and Sundance are outlaws and there’ll be no avoiding their fate. Featuring perhaps both the scariest cliff jump AND the greatest final frame ever screened, as well as two of the most charming leading men in history, this is a film audiences understandably fall in love with.
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly
The definitive spaghetti western and probably the definitive horseback role for Clint Eastwood, it’s hard to believe now that The Good, the Bad and the Ugly was panned by critics upon its initial release. Regardless, discussing the best is one thing but discussing favourites is often another, and The Good, the Bad and the Ugly is many a film nerd’s most cherished western. Set during the Civil War, the titular trio’s quest for stolen gold often takes place against a deliriously chaotic background. Absolutely peerless filmmaking.
Blazing Saddles
Giving a whole new meaning to the revisionist western, Blazing Saddles is also one of the greatest American comedies ever committed to screen. Directed by Mel Brooks and co-written by Richard Pryor, the fact that the film ever appeared out of the Warner Bros. studio is something of a minor miracle, although the crafty Brooks had ensured from the outset that he would have control of the final cut. If there were any remaining myths about the Wild West, Brooks skewered them with this lewd satire on the racism obscured by traditional frontier storytelling.
| 71 |
| Vote |
subscribe to this blog





































Comment by Bryn
Horrorphile
I think they've tried on numerous occasions to resurrect the Western (Pale Rider, Wyatt Earp, Unforgiven, Dances With Wolves, etc), but it's never really caught on ...
I'd also mention the two earlier Sergio Leone flicks, A Fistful of Dollars and For a Few Dollars More, great stuff.
I have to add that I enjoyed many of those TV shows I grew up on; The High Chaparral, Bonanza, The Virginian, The Big Valley ...
No Shane?
What about Westworld
Comment by Matt Shea
20/20 Filmsight
Westworld - there's something I need to check out.
Comment by David O'Connell
Screen Fanatic
Unforgiven is probably my all time favourite though there's an insane genius to The Good, the Bad, the Weird that's irresistable.
I still say Costner's Open Range is an underrated masterpiece - and dammit I'm going to pull out Tombstone very shortly to see how it flies in the 21st century!!
Comment by Matt Shea
20/20 Filmsight
Yeah, it's Tombstone time indeed. The Quick and the Dead flew straight past me when it was first released - I only caught it about five years ago. Highly recommended.
Need to check out Open Range.
Comment by Bryn
Horrorphile
I haven't seen Open Range either.
I have a post-apocalyptic Western feature in my head, which I need to get on paper.
Comment by Matt Shea
20/20 Filmsight
Comment by Bryn
Horrorphile
Comment by Matt Shea
20/20 Filmsight
Comment by ShaunK
Screen Adventure
2 of which happen to be the greatest 2 of all time, no contest
Comment by JohnDoe
Film & TV on DVD
Surprised the 3.10 to Yuma remake made it. That film was so let down by Russell Crowe dressed as a dandy while the rest of the cast reeked of authentic frontier living. Also the ending was downright retarded when you have spent most of the script emphasizing how handicapped Bale's character is and then have him leaping tall buildings in a single bound. I do love the Delmer Davis original though.
I did a post sometime back on 21 Great westerns you may not have seen. Part 1 is HERE and Part 2 is HERE. If you interested.
For modern westerns Open Range, Ride With The Devil and Three Burials are the highlights for me.
Comment by Mr Nice Guy
Pop Culturist
Pop Rock Factory
Comment by Matt Shea
20/20 Filmsight
Bloody hell JD - remind me not to wear my Sunday best in front of ye. 3:10 does divide people, but I loved the ending: Foster's character just kicking up the stakes by immediately putting a bounty on Bale's character's head - mayhem. As for his disability, I tend to think its inclusion is more metaphorical - as a man, he's incomplete etc - and serves to make the bad guys continually underestimate him. By the end, he's got nothing left to lose - so it's sheer force of will that gets him and Wade to the station (with a little bit of Wade's help, of course).
Indeed MNG, indeed. Tombstone is the great unknown - is it as good as any of us remember? It's receiving a rewatch shortly. Thanks for reading.
Comment by Mountain Fog
Infognito
Screen Trek
QUOTE ME NO QUOTES!
sorry I didn't get my list to you in time!
My pooter and my VOIP phone system went down, for 48 hours no less, and I had this in my drafts outbox and forgot...
But, we have many of the same picks anyway!
Great list you have there too.
1: Unforgiven:
When I first saw this film it was a powerful experience, as it broke the mould of previous westerns in that it was hard and unglamorising of that era of psychopaths with six shooter side arms.
2: The Wild Bunch:
Love Ernest Borgnine and William Holden, and Sam Peckinpah, well; there is no better director to capture the enormous skies and vistas of the old Wild West, well, besides John Ford.
3: High Noon:
(I am showing my age again...) well Gary Cooper is the quintessential lawman, a great movie by any accounts.
4: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly:
The spaghetti Western with the whole enchilada...yeah I know mixed metaphors/cultures, the action swift and brutal and Clint is fabbo, fullstop!
5: Fist Full of Dollars:
Yeah well, I’m a Clint fan and loved that era of spaghetti Westerns!
6: Blazing Saddles: fell out of my seat laughing with my mates, literally, but we were young and silly, still love it though.
(equal 6th)
6: Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid;
Redford and Newman, well, they were soooo cute!
7: The Magnificent Seven:
When I saw it, as a kid, I was totally rapt by it, then, when at NIDA, I learned of and then saw, Kurosawa's original, Seven Samurai. Interesting that you point out Kurosawa aped Westerns himself.
But, it is a childhood fave still, and you gotta love Yul baby!
8: High Plains Drifter:
Clint's foray into direction while starring in this marvellously black hearted tale.
9: Stagecoach:
The ever brilliant John Ford at the helm, this is a John Wayne classic, with my other fave Western character actor Andy Devine. I saw this in my childhood years before I knew what a bastard deal the poor hapless Indian nations of America got from the white invaders, which continues to this day!
10: True Grit: (1969)
The late great John Wayne, who was the very encapsulation of all things Western, was my childhood hero. I can't remember which film it came from, but, his famous line, "Is that a gun I see before me?" said in that dead pan drawl, is a line I will never forget and used to imitate in my younger, even sillier years, much to the amusement of all those who heard it. Sadly, today, most wouldn't know who I was imitating.
Post Script:
(11): True Grit: (2011)
I am sure I will like this film, but as I have not seen it yet, I am including it here as a presumptive inclusion.
TV:
Will Rogers, Cisco Kid, The Rifleman, Bonanza, to name but a few.
cheers
fog
Comment by Anonymous
(Back to Ford, Stagecoach is a MUCH better film than The Searchers, because Ford still had some sense of *restraint,* all of which was thrown out the window by the time he made The Searchers.)
Comment by Matt Shea
20/20 Filmsight
Comment by JohnDoe
Film & TV on DVD