Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Blogs | Writers | Paid | My Orble | Login
 
Reviews, previews and chuckling and snorting...

Sanctum 3D

January 31st 2011 03:21
by Matt Shea
Sanctum 3D

James Cameron’s name is plastered all over the advertising material for Sanctum (he acted as executive producer) but precious few of the filmmaker’s signature touches have made it into this Australian adventure thriller. There’s no sci-fi, no strong female characters, and little in the way of dependable dialogue. Even the script could have done with CamBam’s workmanlike groove to sort out its deficiencies.

Sanctum is very much an Australian film, albeit an Australian film made for foreign markets. By this I mean there are plenty of cringe-inducing, wooden ockerisms thrown about as Frank McGuire (Richard Roxburgh) and his hardy crew of can-do larrikins go about exploring a massive cave system hollowed into the side of a Papa New Guinean mountain. Frank is convinced that the cave runs under the mountain and into the sea, and he’s determined to find the route.

Of course, for every salt of the earth, hard working Aussie there’s a blowhard moneyman in control of the operation. In Sanctum it’s Carl (Horatio Hornblower Ioan Gruffudd, swimming upstream against an appalling American accent), a glory-seeking adventurer who is funding Frank’s research. Carl has a grudging respect for Frank and his achievements, but is much closer to Frank’s son, Josh (Rhys Wakefield).

Carl and Josh join Frank’s subterranean expedition right when a storm is blowing in. Of course, the characters make all sorts of underestimations and poorly reasoned judgement calls, leading them to become stranded underground just as the storm turns into a cyclone and the cave begins to flood. It won’t be long before people start dying and the survivors bicker with each other over what to do next.

Watching Sanctum is initially a groan-worthy experience. The early dialogue dealt to the players is abysmal, and the performers struggle as a result. On top of this, the clichés are quickly ordered and stacked: Josh and Frank don’t get along, Carl and Frank don’t get along, Carl’s risk-taking jeopardises the crew, Frank’s grouchiness alienates the crew. Making things worse are some rudimentary special effects highlighted by Sanctum’s 3D viewing experience. I think I’ve done my dash with 3D: the hit in brightness is bad enough in a normal film, but is particularly frustrating when taking on the darker hues of Sanctum. Perhaps it added to the claustrophobia, but I’d have to watch it again without glasses to know, and I suspect that the film would have been better without the technology.



Still, when the talking stops, the action starts and you no longer have the time to decipher some of the ropier special effects, Sanctum improves considerably. It’s a solid high-concept idea for a film, and director Alister Grierson and his crew nail many of the set pieces. Screenwriters Andrew Wight and John Garvin weren’t afraid to up the bodycount either, which is refreshing by modern standards, and helps Sanctum avoid the ‘Goonies on Steroids’ tag (with Dan Wyllie as Chunk) it was in danger of earning.

Roxburgh too is much more convincing as a leading man once the action starts: it may be Josh’s story, but it’s the hardened figure of Frank who makes most of the decisions. Wakefield does a decent job of playing the younger central character and Wyllie is an engaging presence as Frank’s trusted number two, although Gruffudd remains woeful throughout as Carl –you can’t really blame him, given what he has to work with. The rest of the cast hardly rate a mention, the ladies in particular being given precious little to do.

Things drag quite a bit towards the end of Sanctum, and the order of demise could have been fine-tuned for the sake of raising the stakes, but by-and-large this is a solid genre film. Despite its by-the-numbers nature and appalling dialogue, the script is a work of art compared to some of the screenwriting Australia produces. Take some earplugs for the first 20 minutes and don’t be afraid to mentally check out before the end, but Sanctum deserves to do decent business.



I say: If the action scenes weren’t up to snuff I’d remember a lot more of the bad, but Sanctum is worth seeing, particularly if you enjoy exploring the outer limits of your claustrophobia.

See it for: Hornblower’s battle cry.



*This image is from Blogomatic 3000

42
Vote
Add To: del.icio.us Digg Furl Spurl.net StumbleUpon Yahoo


   
subscribe to this blog 


   

   


Comments
8 Comments. [ Add A Comment ]

Comment by David O'Connell

January 31st 2011 03:42
Was desperately hoping you weren't going to obliterate this in your review Matt. I'm seeing it tonight and that might have been the final nail!
The bad dialogue and cliched characters are to be expected I guess, they're looking to create entertainment for the masses and it sounds like it's acceptable on those grounds. I can live with that.

Totally agree with you about 3D too - really sick to death of it; the novelty has more than worn off. It adds absolutely nothing but a headache to the whole screening experience.

Comment by Mountain Fog

January 31st 2011 05:16
I'm seeing this tonight, so I'll read the rest of your review after that.

I did read the opening few paragraphs which has dampened my ardour ofr the flick..

What is going on with Oz film?

I know US money is backing projects, but to not resist bringing two dimensional cardboard ocker characters into play and then not using real Yanks for Americans is harking back to our earlier 1970s cringing social symptoms.

pity..

fog

Comment by Matt Shea

January 31st 2011 06:58
Yeah gents, withhold final judgement until you have seen this. Once you read the whole review, Fog, you'll see that I certainly didn't hate it - there are a lot of positives.

But yeah, you'll find yourselves cringing at some of the early dialogue, and a few moments elicit laughter more than anything else - one (well, two) in particular that I won't mention for spoiler reasons.

Comment by ShaunK

February 1st 2011 21:09
larikins meets 3D, how could anyone resistst.....must have been the thoughts of James Cameron.......wow......amazing what the right contacts can do for you.....I''d love to know how he got involved......

Anywho, I had no desire to even see this one......thanks for largely confirming my suspicions......what is it about hearing the same accent I hear every bloody day in my life, on screen, and even thicker that seems to be so off putting for me - am I that unpatriotic, perhaps.....or maybe it's just negative reinforcement from all the bad aussie films that have been made.

sigh.....disillusioned Shaun.....signing out....

Comment by Matt Shea

February 1st 2011 23:26
Yeah, a little bizarre Shaun, although I can imagine him being impressed by the concept.

This isn't irredeemably bad, but could have been better, for sure. I think I ended up liking it a bit more than Dave and Fog, anyway.

Comment by Anonymous

February 5th 2011 07:11
Well, Matt,
I came, I saw, I left unimpressed...
and frankly very annoyed that another load of horseshit has hit Oz screens...

I have unloaded my review, and I mean unloaded, it is probably my most caustic ever, and deservedly so.

I suspect Garvin's relationship with Cameron may have caused the tiro driector Grierson to keep his critical eye closed, then again, his Kokoda, which he wrote and directed was also criticised for the lack of depth in character development, whereas the technical side, the way ti was shot, was lauded.

Similarly with Sanctum.

cheers

fog

Comment by Alexander_from_Russia

February 20th 2011 13:16
Hello guys, i was wathing this movie, its cool stuff, i ve read many critics of it but the main point is = the will of survival, and if you have a relevance to diving you can get my point about panic while you try to help with buddy breathing and You need to accept that you have to swim away from someone who is in panic stage to survive!!! easy to critisize instead of do something like that!!!

Add A Comment

To create a fully formatted comment please click here.


CLICK HERE TO LOGIN | CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Name or Orble Tag
Home Page (optional)
Comments
Bold Italic Underline Strikethrough Separator Left Center Right Separator Quote Insert Link Insert Email
Notify me of replies
Your Email Address
(optional)
(required for reply notification)
Submit
More Posts
1 Posts
3 Posts
3 Posts
1282 Posts dating from March 2006
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:
0

Matt Shea's Blogs

I have no other blogs :(
Moderated by Matt Shea
Copyright © 2012 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]