Read + Write + Report
Home | Start a blog | About Orble | FAQ | Blogs | Writers | Paid | My Orble | Login
 
Reviews, previews and chuckling and snorting...

Is the internet really killing American movies?

August 13th 2008 23:33
IT Crowd piracy advertisement
Film bloggers are rolling their eyes en masse as we sit down, sigh and read Elizabeth Wurtzel's hole-ridden editorial in the Wall Street Journal. It's called:

The Internet is Ruining America's Movies and Music

It must be nice to get to write for the Wall Street Journal, complaining that things aren't as glorious as they used to be? She starts off lamenting on the loss of the outrageous rock star:

"The old-fashioned rock star has gone the way of the dodo and the dinosaur. Never again will we have another crazy-as-all-getout Axl Rose, another Jim Morrison who mistakes himself for a poet and has the hypnotic ability to convince a substantial audience it is so, or another Bob Dylan who changes the way a generation sees itself and the world."

Her claim? That illegal downloading of music files and even LEGAL downloads have turned consumers away from the idea of 'the album' and towards singles, which has oriented the industry to produce big hits.

Perhaps. I can only imagine the good aspect of the means of digital distribution: I get to listen to things that I would have never imagined were possible.

For example, Lemon Demon's "Marketland"



Weird enough for me, with a damn catchy chorus.

Or The Best of Bootie, a free album of all the best mashups that hit some of the wildest cities in the Western nations.

Not to mention Jonathan Coulton, who became wildly successful thanks, in part, to the Internet.

But we're here to talk film, and Wurtzel has an opinion on that, too.

"But between Internet piracy, the fact that huge markets like China tend to disobey IP protocols, and a foolhardy tendency of studios to make unwise, profit-sharing deals with bankable talent, movies are not making money the way they used to or the way they should. And now that any old anybody with opposable thumbs can operate a digital camera, international markets have found they favor the locally produced fare over yet another sequel to "Rush Hour." Bombay prefers Bollywood to Hollywood."

Here we get to the crux of Wurtzel's irritation... she longs for a time gone by, when America was the cultural center of the world. Where music and film would flow outward into the greedy hands of the foreign markets, eager to snap up our stars and our contrived Hollywood plots.

From that quote, what are her major gripes? IP violations and piracy, though you could counter that by arguing that people that steal movies are the ones that are unlikely to buy them in the first place. Still, it's one of the only reasonable arguments from the article.

Amazingly, Wurtzel then pins the blame on "old anybody" that makes indie movies with digital equipment, as if this is a terrible thing. You'd be hard pressed to find a film critic that cannot find SOME value in the accessibility of filmmaking, thanks to digital video. While many of us long for the old film days, the low cost of DV has brought us some incredible cinema from around the world.

And it's the 'around the world' part that Wurtzel has a problem with: "International markets have found they favour the locally produced fare" and "Bombay prefers Bollywood to Hollywood". Is Wurtzel so out-of-touch that she find this to be unacceptable? Should we criticize people for wanting to watch movies from their own country?

Karina Longworth at SpoutBlog does a far better job than I at disarming Wurtzel's piece:

"Though Wurtzel laments a de-emphasis on “talent” in pop music, she has not a single qualitative statement to make about a single contemporary film––she’s simply concerned that studios are making more money off their back catalogs than new releases, and that foreign territories “have found they favor the locally produced fare over yet another sequel to Rush Hour.”

Thankfully, the Internet has allowed us to read and discover more about cinema than would be possible otherwise - people like Wurtzel are very interested in controlling the pipes, charging you full prices for movies that you're not that interested in. She laments the stumbling of the American movie industry, but this is the same industry that has, in the space of a month, put out "The Dark Knight", "Tropic Thunder" and "Pineapple Express", movies that will gleefully line the pockets of movie studios with silver.


*this image is from AllNewsPlace.com, and is a still from a hilarious episode of the IT Crowd. Watch it here!

117
Vote
Add To: del.icio.us Digg Furl Spurl.net StumbleUpon Yahoo


   
subscribe to this blog 


   

   


Comments
16 Comments. [ Add A Comment ]

Comment by Cibbuano

August 13th 2008 23:45
Followup: as a terrific example of how downloading actually helps movies or music, I recently bought DVDs of "The IT Crowd" and "The Mighty Boosh", two excellent comedy series from the UK, which I sneakily downloaded to watch first.

Comment by Damo

August 14th 2008 01:28
Too much to explain about what is wrong with the music industry. But in short it was an industry that sold music as a quality item, it is now selling music as if it is nothing more than another cornflakes box on the market. Musicians rarely get a cent and the companies still cry poor.

That being said we all miss the old steam engine days, where we were free and happier than we are today. However back then people missed the horse buggy days.

The new reality is that the Internet exists and people make choices. It would be extremely condescending to call people stupid because they choose another type of music than what you consider life changing.

Comment by Cibbuano

August 14th 2008 02:28
Damo, that's right... no matter what, we'll always have people that cry for the good ol' days...

..I've heard that a group of prominent musicians are suing the record companies. After all, the RIAA uses the reason that we're 'stealing from the artists' as discouragement. Well, the artists haven't received any of that money!

Comment by Cibbuano

August 14th 2008 03:30
smooth, I can understand. Who wants to drop that much money on something you're not sure about? We need cheaper movies, I think!

Comment by Bryn

August 14th 2008 07:52
That song was reeeeeeally annoying.

I am slowly and steadily collecting every one of my favourite movies on DVD. I love the process; the comparing of editions and finally the acquisition. I nearly have all 100 of my favourite films (yes, I actually have a list, I'm that much of a cinephile). Plus another 400 DVDs of other movies that float my boat.
So I might not be going out to the cinema as often as I used to, but I'm still supporting the industry.

Comment by Nathan 1

August 14th 2008 08:59
She does have a point that studios are less willing to take risks on good quality scripts and instead go with the safe 'bankable talent' option where they are guarantted money. This will probably put people off gonig to the cinema and lead them to downloading instead. But like you say, if poor US films are motivating an outbreak of localised filmmaking then this is good; gives the little guys a chance to have a go. I do like Elizabeth Wurtzel's books though, she's a very good wrtier and deals with the subjects of depression and her own struggle with sincerity and wit.

Comment by Cibbuano

August 14th 2008 22:21
Nathan - I'm not familiar with Wurtzel?

Yes, studios are going for bankable options, which is why we're treated to horrible remakes, reimaginings and sequels. I'm sure the Australian film industry would love it if Australia became a little less US-polarized in the cinemas, though...

Comment by Cibbuano

August 14th 2008 22:24
Bryn, I don't know why, but I dig that song. Well, I like the weird songwriting skills of that Lemon Demon guy.

I'm sure you've pumped in more than your share of revenue for the film industry!

I don't really want to collect DVDs, though... I still find them to be inconvenient... the stupid opening warning titles, the terrible DVD menus.

No, I prefer to rip my DVDs to a file and store it on a media center - then it's accessible, immediately!

Comment by Clint Emry

August 14th 2008 22:34
market market market, it is all marketing.

the situation becomes very convoluted.

Comment by Nathan 1

August 14th 2008 23:42
She's very good Cib. She wrote Prozac Nation which was made into a film starring Christina Richi as Wurtzel, though it does not do the book any justice despite good perfromances. She also wrote More Now and Again where she talks about her affair with cocaine and kleptomania. Bitch is also good but is not a memoir but a tribute to all the 'bitches' of media; it's pretty much a femminist rant but still a good read.

Comment by Bryn

August 15th 2008 01:27
Cibby, you're of a different breed.
Call me old-fahsioned.
Purist.
Die hard romantic.
I have to have the hardcopy with the packaging and the extra features.
Just as I can't stand music as MP3 files, apart from the convenience of having them on an MP3 player. I love vinyl. I love handling vinyl.
To have movies stored as files on a computer depresses the hell out of me.
Most DVDs I have don't have bullshit trailers at the beginning. There can be a little shite to wade through. But I tolerate it.

Comment by Cibbuano

August 15th 2008 01:49
clint, it is a lot of marketing, unfortunately.

nathan, ah, prozac nation... I've heard of it. I don't know if I'll read it after this nasty article...

bryn, I can sympathize... I don't enjoy having MP3s either, I prefer vinyl. My records are in Canada, and the last time I saw them, it was a moment of pure joy.

DVDs, though, are hardly the same... they're a convenient form of storing movies, no different than storing them as files.

If I started collecting film reels, that might push me over the edge - I'd be down with that nonsense...

Comment by Bryn

August 15th 2008 03:09
But I'm a romantic ... like books on shelves, I want people to appreciate and sift through my movie collection when they're round at my pad.

Comment by OnlineWriter

August 15th 2008 03:10
Wow, Bryn is exactly like this 60 year old guy I know. He will NOT listen to MP3's and only has exact DVD replicas if he can't buy them.

He's got the most amazing vinyl collection on earth I think too haha.

I'm not so picky.


Comment by Bryn

August 15th 2008 05:41
Sheesh, I've been compared to a 60 year old. Bizarre, since physically people mistake me for a 25 year old.

Comment by Miswanderlust

September 6th 2008 01:51
This is a great post. High five Cib.

Add A Comment

To create a fully formatted comment please click here.


CLICK HERE TO LOGIN | CLICK HERE TO REGISTER

Name or Orble Tag
Home Page (optional)
Comments
Bold Italic Underline Strikethrough Separator Left Center Right Separator Quote Insert Link Insert Email
Notify me of replies
Notify extra people about this comment
Is this a private comment?
List the Email Addresses or Orble Tags of the people you would like to be notified about this comment


One per line max of 30

List the Email Addresses or Orble Tags of the people you would like to be notified about this private comment thread. Only the people in this list will be able to see or reply to your comment.


One per line max of 30

Your Name
(for the email going out to the above list, it can be different to your Orble Tag)
Your Email Address
(optional)
(required for reply notification)
Submit
More Posts
1 Posts
14 Posts
10 Posts
1142 Posts dating from March 2006
Email Subscription
Receive e-mail notifications of new posts on this blog:
0

Matt Shea's Blogs

I have no other blogs :(
Moderated by Matt Shea
Copyright © 2006 2007 2008 On Topic Media PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved. Design by Vimu.com.
On Topic Media ZPages: Sydney |  Melbourne |  Brisbane |  London |  Birmingham |  Leeds     [ Advertise ] [ Contact Us ] [ Privacy Policy ]